Home About Services Grant Writing & Fundraising Program Evaluation Nonprofit Mentoring Academy FAQ Events Blog Contact Book a Consultation
Nonprofit Strategy

Nonprofit Board of Directors: Roles, Positions and Legal Duties

Published 9 min read
Quick answer

A nonprofit board of directors is the governing body legally responsible for a nonprofit. Members owe the duties of care, loyalty and obedience, and the board sets mission and strategy, hires and oversees the executive director, and protects the organization's finances. Most boards elect a chair, vice chair, secretary and treasurer. Minimum board size is set by state law.

Nonprofit board of directors meeting around a table in a community room

Many nonprofit founders build a board quickly because the paperwork requires one, then realize later that nobody agreed on what the board is actually for. Whether you are recruiting your first three directors or trying to get an established board to govern instead of manage, the basics are the same, and they are worth getting right early.

Want a second set of eyes on your next step?

Book a free 30-minute consultation with Dr. Hopkins. Walk away with a clear next step, whether you work with us or not.

Book a Free Consultation →

What is a nonprofit board of directors?

A nonprofit board of directors is the group of people legally responsible for governing a nonprofit corporation. The board does not own the organization. It holds it in trust for the public and the mission, which means setting direction, hiring and overseeing the executive director, protecting assets and making sure the organization follows the law and its own bylaws.

BoardSource describes the board as "the governing body ultimately responsible for a nonprofit," with specific legal and ethical responsibilities to the organization. In a small, all volunteer organization, board members may also run programs. Once there is paid staff, the National Council of Nonprofits explains, board members provide foresight, oversight and insight rather than steering day to day operations.

This article is general education, not legal advice. Nonprofit law is mostly state law, so your state's nonprofit corporation act, your articles of incorporation and your bylaws control the specifics for your organization.

Nonprofit board members owe three legal duties: the duty of care, the duty of loyalty and the duty of obedience. Together they require directors to pay attention and make informed decisions, put the organization's interests ahead of their own, and keep the nonprofit faithful to its mission, its bylaws and the law. They belong to every director.

The National Council of Nonprofits summarizes the three duties this way:

Duty What it asks of a director What it looks like in practice
Care Ensure prudent use of all assets, including facilities, people and good will Read the financials before meetings, ask questions, attend regularly
Loyalty Advance the mission first, recognize and disclose conflicts, decide in the nonprofit's best interest Sign an annual conflict of interest disclosure and step out of votes where you have an interest
Obedience Ensure the nonprofit obeys applicable laws, follows its bylaws and adheres to its stated purpose Approve only programs that fit the mission, confirm required filings happen

BoardSource notes that these standards come from well established principles of nonprofit corporation law, and that several states have statutes adopting some variation of them. South Carolina is one example. Its Nonprofit Corporation Act requires a director to act in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise, and in a manner the director reasonably believes is in the corporation's best interests (S.C. Code Section 33-31-830). The same chapter sets rules for director conflict of interest transactions in Section 33-31-831.

What are nonprofit board member responsibilities?

Nonprofit board member responsibilities fall into two groups. The full board is responsible for mission, strategy, hiring and evaluating the chief executive, financial oversight and legal compliance. Each individual member is responsible for attending meetings, preparing in advance, serving on committees, following conflict of interest policies, contributing personally and representing the organization well in the community.

BoardSource's widely used framework lists ten basic responsibilities of nonprofit boards:

  1. Determine mission and purpose.
  2. Select the chief executive.
  3. Support and evaluate the chief executive.
  4. Ensure effective planning.
  5. Monitor and strengthen programs and services.
  6. Ensure adequate financial resources.
  7. Protect assets and provide proper financial oversight.
  8. Build a competent board.
  9. Ensure legal and ethical integrity.
  10. Enhance the organization's public standing.

Planning is where many boards drift. A board that adopts a nonprofit strategic plan and reviews progress against it at each meeting has a natural agenda and is less likely to slide into operational details.

Resources are the other area where expectations get fuzzy. BoardSource's list of individual responsibilities includes making a personal financial contribution, and the full board shares responsibility for adequate funding. Board giving policies, give or get, and ways to help without asking are a topic of their own, covered in our guide to nonprofit board fundraising.

What are the positions on a nonprofit board?

The standard positions on a nonprofit board are chair (sometimes called president), vice chair, secretary and treasurer, plus at large directors who hold no office. BoardSource notes that most bylaws include these officer positions regardless of board size. Committee chairs, such as a finance or governance committee chair, are additional leadership roles filled by directors.

Here is how BoardSource describes each role:

Position Core role Typical tasks
Chair or president Leads the board and partners with the chief executive Runs meetings, helps set agendas, appoints committee chairs, coordinates the chief executive's annual evaluation
Vice chair Fills in for the chair and provides succession Takes on assigned projects, prepares to step into the chair role
Secretary Keeps or oversees the board's records Takes or reviews minutes, keeps records accurate and safe, sends required meeting notices
Treasurer Oversees finances and budget Usually chairs the finance committee, makes sure the board gets timely financial reports
At large director Full voting member without an office Serves on committees, brings skills and community connections

State law can set officer requirements too. South Carolina's act, for example, says that unless the articles or bylaws provide otherwise, a corporation shall have a president, a secretary and a treasurer, and the bylaws or board must assign one officer responsibility for minutes and records (S.C. Code Section 33-31-840). Specific duties come from your bylaws or board resolutions, so write them down.

How many board members does a nonprofit need?

The minimum number of board members a nonprofit needs is set by state law, not by the IRS, and it varies by state. South Carolina requires at least three. Beyond that floor, the IRS encourages a board large enough to bring needed skills and a broad public interest, but not so large it struggles to decide.

In South Carolina, Section 33-31-803 says a board "must consist of three or more directors," with the exact number set in the articles or bylaws. If you are organized in another state, look up that state's nonprofit corporation act or check the state specific board resources the National Council of Nonprofits links from its board roles page.

The IRS's guidance on governance makes a practical point about size. Very small boards risk lacking the skills and broad public representation needed to govern, while very large boards may have a harder time getting down to business. The IRS also says that, whatever the size, a board should include independent members and should not be dominated by employees or people with family or business ties to one another. Form 990 asks for both the number of voting members and how many are independent.

Consider a hypothetical food pantry in Florence, SC, founded by a married couple with a close friend as the third director. That meets the state minimum, but two directors are related and all three run operations. Adding two or three independent members with finance, legal or community experience would strengthen oversight.

What is the difference between a working board and a governing board?

A working board is one where directors also do much of the hands on work, such as running programs or keeping the books, usually because there is little or no staff. A governing board focuses on oversight and strategy and leaves daily operations to an executive director and staff. Many organizations move from one to the other as they grow.

Most small nonprofits pass through three stages:

Board type When it fits Main risk
Founding board First months, often friends and family of the founder Too few independent voices, unclear roles
Working board No or minimal staff, board members volunteer in operations Oversight gets lost when the people doing the work also check the work
Governing board Paid executive director and staff in place Micromanaging staff, or drifting into rubber stamping

The key shift is lanes. The board decides what the organization should accomplish and checks whether it is happening. The executive director decides how and manages the people doing it. The National Council of Nonprofits calls hiring, compensating, supervising and evaluating the chief executive one of the most important responsibilities many boards have. On whether that executive should also hold a board seat, BoardSource recommends non-voting membership unless the law does not permit it.

If you are still forming your organization, our guide on how to start a nonprofit covers where recruiting a founding board fits among the other early steps.

What governance policies does the IRS ask nonprofits about?

The IRS asks about governance on Form 990, Part VI. Questions cover the number of voting and independent board members, whether meetings were documented, whether the full board received the Form 990 before filing, and whether the organization has written conflict of interest, whistleblower and document retention policies and an independent process for setting executive pay.

The 2025 Form 990 notes that Section B asks about policies "not required by the Internal Revenue Code." A "No" is not automatically a violation, but the answers are public, funders read them, and the IRS says it reviews whether organizations have adopted these policies.

Form 990, Part VI line What it asks
1a and 1b Number of voting board members, and how many are independent
8a Did the organization contemporaneously document governing body meetings?
11a Was a complete copy of the Form 990 given to all board members before filing?
12a to 12c Written conflict of interest policy, annual disclosures, and monitoring
13 Written whistleblower policy
14 Written document retention and destruction policy
15a and 15b Independent review, comparability data and documentation when setting executive and officer pay

A board that can answer "Yes" across this list is usually a board that is meeting its duties of care and loyalty in practice.

How do you build a strong board for a small nonprofit?

To build a strong board for a small nonprofit, confirm your state's legal requirements, write clear bylaws and role descriptions, recruit for the skills and community connections you lack, orient every new member, adopt the core governance policies, and evaluate the board's own performance regularly. Most organizations can put this foundation in place within one board year.

A practical sequence:

  1. Check the law. Confirm your state's minimum number of directors and any officer requirements, and make sure your bylaws match.
  2. Write role descriptions. Put expectations for all members, plus each officer, in writing before anyone is asked to join.
  3. Recruit for gaps. List the skills, perspectives and connections the board needs, such as finance, law, the community you serve, and fill them deliberately.
  4. Orient new members. Walk through the mission, budget, bylaws, policies and current strategic priorities.
  5. Adopt core policies. Start with conflict of interest, whistleblower and document retention policies, then a written process for setting executive pay.
  6. Assess and renew. BoardSource lists building a competent board, including periodic self evaluation, as a core board responsibility.

Board development is often easier with an outside facilitator. Prepared to Impact supports boards and executive directors with strategic planning and nonprofit strategy, and Dr. Lauren Hopkins serves as Board President of the South Carolina Chapter of the Grant Professionals Association, so she brings a board member's perspective to the work.

Ready to get prepared?

Tell us what your organization is working toward. A free consultation is the fastest way to map the path forward.

Book a Free Consultation →

Frequently asked questions

Do you get paid to be on a nonprofit board of directors?

Usually not. The National Council of Nonprofits notes that the vast majority of board members for charitable nonprofits serve as volunteers without compensation. Paying directors is not automatically prohibited, but the IRS says a charity may not pay more than reasonable compensation, and the decision should be made by people with no financial interest in it. State law and your bylaws also apply.

What are the 5 responsibilities of a board member for a nonprofit?

Lists vary, but five that appear in nearly every framework are setting the mission and direction, hiring and supporting the chief executive, ensuring effective planning, protecting assets through financial oversight, and ensuring legal and ethical integrity. BoardSource's full list has ten basic responsibilities, adding program monitoring, adequate resources, building a competent board and enhancing public standing.

Can the executive director serve on the nonprofit board?

It depends on state law and your bylaws, but BoardSource recommends that chief executives serve as non-voting members of the board unless the law does not permit that. The executive director's input in board discussion is valuable. Keeping the vote with independent directors avoids conflicts of interest and keeps a clear line between oversight and day to day management.

Can one person hold two officer positions on a nonprofit board?

Sometimes. In South Carolina, the nonprofit corporation statute allows the same individual to hold more than one office at the same time. Other states have different rules, and some restrict particular combinations. Check your state's nonprofit corporation law and your bylaws before combining roles, and remember that spreading roles across members also spreads the workload and the oversight.

Sources

  1. National Council of Nonprofits, Board Roles and Responsibilities (accessed November 2, 2026)
  2. BoardSource, Board Member Roles and Responsibilities (accessed November 2, 2026)
  3. IRS, Governance and Related Topics: 501(c)(3) Organizations (accessed November 2, 2026)
  4. IRS, Form 990 (2025), Part VI: Governance, Management, and Disclosure (accessed November 2, 2026)
  5. South Carolina Code of Laws, Title 33, Chapter 31: South Carolina Nonprofit Corporation Act (accessed November 2, 2026)

Published . Last updated .