Home About Services Grant Writing & Fundraising Program Evaluation Nonprofit Mentoring Academy FAQ Events Blog Contact Book a Consultation
Nonprofit Strategy

Nonprofit Board Fundraising: What Board Members Should Do

Published 8 min read
Quick answer

In nonprofit board fundraising, board members share responsibility for making sure the organization has the money it needs. That usually means every member makes a personally meaningful gift each year and helps raise other funds by opening doors, hosting, thanking donors or joining asks. Staff manage the fundraising program, and the board supports it.

Nonprofit board fundraising discussion among board members at a meeting

Few topics create more quiet tension in a nonprofit than the board's role in raising money. Executive directors wish the board would do more, and board members often are not sure what "more" means or feel uneasy asking friends for money.

Want a second set of eyes on your next step?

Book a free 30-minute consultation with Dr. Hopkins. Walk away with a clear next step, whether you work with us or not.

Book a Free Consultation →

What is nonprofit board fundraising?

Nonprofit board fundraising is the board's shared responsibility for making sure the organization has the resources to carry out its mission. In practice, it means every board member gives personally each year and helps raise other money by making introductions, hosting, thanking donors, joining donor visits or making asks, while staff manage the fundraising program.

BoardSource describes the board's role as understanding, informing and supporting resource development strategies, and monitoring progress against the fund development plan and goals. That framing is useful because it puts fundraising inside governance. The board is not a sales team. It is the group accountable for the organization's financial health, and helping secure resources is part of that duty.

That does not mean every member must be comfortable asking for a major gift. It does mean every member has a role.

Are board members responsible for fundraising?

Yes. Board members are collectively responsible for making sure the nonprofit has adequate resources, and most boards expect each member to give personally and help raise funds. The specific expectations should be written in a board fundraising policy and explained before someone joins, so new members know what they are agreeing to.

Bridgespan collected perspectives from nonprofit leaders on this question, and one consistent theme was clarity at the start. A consultant quoted in that piece argued that contributions, fundraising and attendance should all be explained before a person joins the board. Surprises after the fact damage trust and lead to disengaged members.

Responsibility also looks different by organization. A large health system board may include members who give six figure gifts. A small, volunteer led board in a rural county may contribute more through relationships and event work than through personal wealth. Both can meet their responsibility if expectations are clear and honored.

What is a give or get policy?

A give or get policy asks each board member to either personally give, or raise from others, a set minimum amount each year. A member might write a $1,500 check, raise $1,500 from their network, or combine the two. It sets a clear floor while allowing members with different resources to contribute in different ways.

BoardSource describes the give or get approach, but it recommends that each board member give at a level significant to them personally and also help raise other funds as appropriate to their experience. In other words, the "get" should not fully replace the "give." A member who raises money but never contributes personally may struggle to ask others with credibility.

Policy type How it works Best fit
Give only Each member makes a personally meaningful gift, no fundraising quota Boards early in building a fundraising culture
Give or get Members give or raise a minimum amount Boards with mixed personal capacity
Give and get Members give personally and raise an additional amount Established boards with strong networks
Minimum gift A set dollar floor for personal giving Boards where funders expect a visible commitment

Whatever you choose, write it down, have the board adopt it, and revisit it every few years.

Why does 100 percent board giving matter?

One hundred percent board giving matters because funders and donors see it as a sign of commitment. BoardSource notes that funders frequently ask whether 100 percent of board members give, and that many foundations only fund organizations where every board member contributes. If the people governing the organization will not invest, outside donors notice.

BoardSource recommends that boards that raise funds aim for 100 percent board member participation, with each gift at a level personally significant to the member. Participation matters more than the total. A board where every member gives $100 tells a stronger story to a foundation than a board where two members give $10,000 and the rest give nothing.

For the hypothetical example of a small literacy nonprofit in Spartanburg, SC, the practice can be simple: the board chair asks for annual pledges at the first meeting of the fiscal year, the treasurer reports participation at each meeting, and the grant writer can confirm 100 percent board giving on every application. It is a small step that strengthens nearly every proposal.

How can board members help fundraise without asking for money?

Board members can help fundraise without making a direct ask by sharing names of potential donors, opening doors to businesses and foundations, hosting small gatherings, signing or adding notes to appeal letters, making thank you calls, attending events with guests, and joining the executive director on donor visits. Each step moves a relationship closer to a gift.

BoardSource lists many of these same activities, including providing names of potential donors, writing or signing fundraising letters, thanking donors personally and accompanying the chief executive on donor and foundation visits.

Thanking deserves special attention. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q4 2025 report found overall donor retention of 43.3 percent, which means most donors do not give again the following year. A board member's personal thank you call is one of the simplest ways to change that, and it requires no asking at all.

How do you build a board fundraising plan?

To build a board fundraising plan, start from your organization's annual fundraising goals, adopt a written board giving policy, ask each member to complete a short commitment form, match members to roles that fit their strengths, provide brief training, and report progress at every board meeting. Most boards can set this up within one or two meetings.

A practical sequence:

  1. Connect to the organization's plan. Board activity should support the targets in your nonprofit fundraising plan, not run on a separate track.
  2. Adopt a written policy. BoardSource suggests a policy setting the expectation of 100 percent board giving at a level personally significant to each member.
  3. Collect annual commitments. A one page form asks each member for their pledge and the two or three fundraising activities they will take on.
  4. Match roles to strengths. Connectors make introductions, hosts hold gatherings, and storytellers speak at events.
  5. Train and equip. BoardSource recommends fundraising training plus practical tools like checklists and sample elevator speeches.
  6. Report and thank. Share participation and progress at every meeting, and thank board members the way you thank donors.

Keep the commitment form simple. A hypothetical example for a youth sports nonprofit might list a personal pledge amount, then ask each member to check two items from a short menu: host one small gathering, make five thank you calls after the year end appeal, introduce two local business owners, attend the annual event with a guest, or join one donor visit. Members choose, staff follow up, and the board chair tracks progress. That structure turns a vague expectation into specific, doable tasks.

What should a board avoid in fundraising?

A board should avoid micromanaging the development staff, setting fundraising goals without a plan behind them, letting a few members carry all the work, and recruiting members only for their wealth. It should also avoid fundraising arrangements that create ethical problems, such as paying anyone a percentage of the money they raise.

That last point comes up often with grants. Grant writing on commission goes against the Grant Professionals Association Code of Ethics and federal cost principles, and Prepared to Impact does not write on commission or pro bono. Boards should also be wary of anyone who guarantees funding, because no one can honestly make that promise.

When a board needs help building a fundraising culture, outside support can make the conversation easier. Prepared to Impact works with boards and executive directors on fundraising strategy and planning, and Dr. Lauren Hopkins serves as Board President of the South Carolina Chapter of the Grant Professionals Association, so she understands the board side of the table.

Ready to get prepared?

Tell us what your organization is working toward. A free consultation is the fastest way to map the path forward.

Book a Free Consultation →

Frequently asked questions

How much should nonprofit board members give?

There is no single right amount. BoardSource recommends that each board member give at a level personally significant to them, so a gift that is meaningful for one member may be modest for another. Some boards set a minimum, while others ask members to make the organization one of their top personal giving priorities. What matters most is 100 percent participation.

What is the 80/20 rule in fundraising?

The 80/20 rule is a rule of thumb that says about 80 percent of contributed revenue tends to come from roughly 20 percent of donors. For boards, it is a reminder that a handful of relationships often carry the budget. Board members who open doors to major donors and help steward them can have an outsized effect on results.

What is the 33% rule for nonprofits?

The 33 percent rule usually means the IRS public support test. Many public charities must show that at least one third of their total support comes from the general public over a five year period, reported on Form 990 Schedule A. A broad donor base, including board giving and board networks, helps an organization meet it.

What should nonprofit board members not do in fundraising?

Board members should not promise donors outcomes or recognition the organization has not approved, accept gifts with restrictions staff cannot honor, or contact major donors without coordinating with staff. They also should not manage day to day fundraising operations. The board sets expectations and supports the work, while the executive director and staff run the program.

Sources

  1. BoardSource, Board Members and Personal Contributions
  2. BoardSource, Board Fundraising Policy: Key Elements and Practical Tips
  3. Bridgespan, Board Fundraising: Give or Get?
  4. Fundraising Effectiveness Project, Q4 2025 Report
  5. IRS, Form 990 Schedule A Public Charity Support Test

Published . Last updated .